The psychology and history of English genitives
In "A correlate of animacy" (9/27/2008) I noted that "A traditional and characteristic example of the role of animacy in English syntax is the way it affects the choice between the two ways of expressing genitive relations, X's Y vs. the Y of X.". I illustrated the effect with this table (from the days when Google gave estimated counts for search results):
| __'s | of __ | ratio | |
| Giuliani | 1.14M | 140K | 8.14 |
| McCain | 23.6M | 4.42M | 5.34 |
| Clinton | 11.6M | 2.81M | 4.13 |
| Obama | 26M | 7.6M | 3.42 |
| Apple | 22.6M | 9.39M | 2.41 |
| IBM | 6.97M | 4.03M | 1.73 |
| Microsoft | 35.5M | 21.3M | 1.67 |
| 17M | 13.4M | 1.27 | |
| America | 113M | 131M | 0.863 |
| Canada | 26.8M | 60.5M | 0.443 |
| Thailand | 3.96M | 11.8M | 0.336 |
| England | 10.9M | 48M | 0.227 |
| Belgium | 799K | 6.31M | 0.127 |
| lithium | 60.7K | 1.73M | 0.035 |
| arsenic | 21.7K | 1.19M | 0.018 |
| silicon | 50.9K | 5.93M | 0.0086 |
| hydrogen | 45.3K | 9.44M | 0.0048 |
| cadmium | 4.01K | 2.2M | 0.0018 |
Read the rest of this entry »




