Back in the 1970s, Julian Jaynes proposed that humans developed language so that the ancestral memories stored in the brain's right hemisphere could be communicated (as hallucinated oracular voices) to the left hemisphere. Then (somehow) the invention of writing changed things (in around 600 BC, by his calculations), so that those oracular voices were mostly lost, and humans developed self-consciousness instead.
At least, that's my memory of the version that I heard him propose in a talk at Bell Labs around the time he published his book. At dinner after the talk, I asked him about the Sumerian Gilgamesh epic, which seems to assume rather modern kinds of consciousness, and his only response was to accuse me of having obviously been educated by Jesuits.
As Jaynes' ideas developed, writing seems to have lost its crucial role in his theory of the bicameral breakdown, which he attributed to more general cultural changes.
Apparently there's now a Julian Jaynes Society, and one of its members has recently published an article under the title "Homer's Greeks had no inner life". The article's summary description:
In Homer's Iliad, we rarely encounter the original Greek word for 'I' or much that refers to internal thought or decision-making. In this controversial article, cultural theorist Brian J. McVeigh argues Princeton psychologist Julian Jaynes got it right when he claimed the Homeric Greeks had no internal life or self-awareness. On the 50th anniversary of Jayne's classic book, The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind, which inspired the HBO series Westworld, McVeigh argues that the ancient Greeks took the voices of their gods as their impetus for action and that they indeed had no inner life.
Read the rest of this entry »