Archive for Counterfactuals

"I didn’t save you because you’re not important."

[This is a guest post from Brett Powley]

I ran into something recently that I thought might be log-worthy. My wife was watching Van Helsing, the TV series, and I heard one of the characters say this:
 
I didn’t save you because you’re not important.
 
Now, what he meant was:
 
I wouldn’t have saved you if you weren’t important.
 
But the more I thought about this, the more I realised that he said exactly the opposite of what he meant. I wondered why I got the ‘right’ interpretation of this the first time, rather than the plain reading which would be something like:
 
You’re not important, so I didn’t save you.

Read the rest of this entry »

Comments (20)