"Knell in the coffin"

« previous post | next post »

From Will Lockett, "We Are Watching The Death of Tesla", Medium 10/18/2024:

This is why the fact that Musk didn’t detail any safety data at ‘We, Robot’ was a knell in the coffin.

Google's AI Overview explains, ignoring the difference in spelling:

The standard metaphorical phrase is "nail in the coffin", of course.

And knell is an easy substitution for nail because it's similar in sound, and has the adjacent meaning of a bell rung slowly to signal a death.

But "knell in the coffin" is far from a typical eggcorn — a funeral bell wouldn't fit in a coffin, so  the substitution is not really plausible; and coffin nails remain a familiar reference, even if modern coffin lids are often fastened shut in other ways.

Still, "knell in the coffin" is Out There, if rarely — for example, from the transcript of a Congressional budget committee  hearing on 9/25/2019, where Bill Johnson is represented as saying:

You know, I believe any discussion on infrastructure, we talk about the Highway
Trust Fund, but one of the other really critical, important, rural infrastructure issues is broadband and building out broadband.

I know that is not funded out of the Highway Trust Fund, but in rural areas like Eastern and Southeastern Ohio, where most of my district, six and a half hours long, from an hour outside of Cleveland to an hour outside of Cincinnati; most of
my district has inadequate broadband service.

In a digital economy, that is a death knell in the coffin of rural communities.

The obligatory (Lockett) screen shot:



4 Comments

  1. J Knight said,

    October 20, 2024 @ 8:22 am

    To add, in the part of the country I live in (Appalachia) knell and nail are pronounced the same, not just similarly.

    [(myl) Good point. And Bill Johnson was born in Roseboro NC, which is not Appalachia, but probably shares the same monophthongization. On the other hand, he cited a "death knell in the coffin" (or at least he was transcribed that way), so there's metaphorical mixture beyond mis-spelling "nail". And Will Lockett is British, though I don't know from which dialectal region.]

  2. Rodger C said,

    October 20, 2024 @ 9:54 am

    And then there's the Appalachian folktale, "Nell in the Coffin." (Not really.)

  3. David L said,

    October 20, 2024 @ 11:04 am

    A death knell in the coffin seems pointless. The people outside won't hear it, and to the person inside it's adding insult to injury.

  4. Jonathan Smith said,

    October 20, 2024 @ 12:18 pm

    @David L OTOH this might preclude that annoying asking of for whom the bell t̵o̵l̵l̵s̵ knells

RSS feed for comments on this post