AI doom as message overload

« previous post | next post »

Norbert Wiener's 1950 book The Human Use of Human Beings makes some uncannily accurate predictions, e.g.

It is the thesis of this book that society can only be understood through a study of the messages and the communication facilities which belong to it; and that in the future development of these messages and communication facilities, messages between man and machines, between machines and man, and between machine and machine, are destined to play an ever-increasing part.

And those messages will be an "ever-increasing part" of an ever-growing whole, alas — just ask anyone who has recently spent time with WorkDay and its ilk ☹️.

Weiner 's predicted "new industrial revolution" has a lot in common with current worries about AI:

Thus the new industrial revolution is a two-edged sword. It may be used for the benefit of humanity, but only if humanity survives long enough to enter a period in which such a benefit is possible. It may also be used to destroy humanity, and if it is not used intelligently it can go very far in that direction.

However, he underestimates the needed development time:

The introduction of the new devices and the dates at which they are to be expected are, of course, largely economic matters, on which I am not an expert. Short of any violent political changes or another great war, I should give a rough estimate that it will take the new tools ten to twenty years to come into their own. 

Thus by 1960 or 1970, he argues,

It is perfectly clear that this will produce an unemployment situation, in comparison with which the present recession and even the depression of the thirties will seem a pleasant joke. This depression will ruin many industries — possibly even the industries which have taken advantage of the new potentialities. 

The 60s and 70s had their problems, but not those problems. So who knows, maybe message-overload will continue to be our experience of AI doom?

 

 

 



7 Comments »

  1. Aviva Mar said,

    October 19, 2026 @ 10:17 pm

    Wiener's line about messages between machine and machine is the one that aged best, I think. A lot of what gets called agentic AI right now is exactly that: one system filling in a form so another system can parse it, with a person copied on the results. If there's a doom in that, it may look less like the mass unemployment he expected by 1960 or 1970 and more like everyone wading through notifications nobody quite wrote. Not a cheerful thought, but a more familiar one.

  2. GO said,

    October 19, 2026 @ 11:17 pm

    WorkDay! Auggh. For a cyber company it has one very large building downtown in my middle sized city.

    Here is an anecdote about machine-to-machine communication – and failures of human-human communication.
    I am shifting from paid academic to 'emeritus'/volunteer status. Despite work and I having long ago agreed my retirement date – and despite it having passed for over a month -I was still receiving WorkDay demands like "do your secondary employment register training module". After several week's trying to speak to a human in HR, I eventually succeeded. To be told that I had to 'resign" in WorkDay. I bit my tongue against saying "This is news to me. And legally, you can't resign from a contract that is spent, let alone by agreed effluxion of time".
    I bit my tongue harder when WorkDay insisted I could only 'resign' on a future date, not the date one actually agreed to leave. That bogus date would then be treated as fact the pension scheme, meaning I risked losing my first month's pension!

  3. KeithB said,

    October 20, 2026 @ 7:10 am

    When I first got my WorkDay request – out of the blue from an external site – I reported it as Spam. Then we started getting messages for required training that was not required for us, and we kept getting them, as well as the emails saying to ignore them.

    I think I will actually have to engage with Workday now since it is locking me out of some of the files I need to access. sigh.

  4. Charles Antaki said,

    October 20, 2026 @ 11:26 am

    I don't think WorkDay has reached UK universities yet – but if it makes employees as excited, not to say ecstatic, as they seem in the pictures on their website, then it'll be welcomed with opened arms.

  5. Andrew Usher said,

    October 21, 2026 @ 7:40 am

    Wiener's time scale may have been wrong, but he had nothing better than to make a very wild guess. He was on more confident ground asserting that it would happen eventually, as were many others. But no one foresaw, and it's still difficult to get people to understand, that society managed to put off the problem only by creating more and more bullshit jobs and bullshit work. From that point of view, the ever-increasing time people spend at work dealing with this nonsense is a feature.

  6. Kirill Shebetov said,

    October 22, 2026 @ 8:46 pm

    GO, was there a route to have the agreed retirement recognised without first submitting “resign” and a future date? Understanding a form’s vocabulary is different from agreeing that its description fits what happened. A correction mechanism still leaves a problem if entering the disputed description is the price of reaching it.

    Beforeword, the project I’m developing, asks whether requirements to learn, repeat, understand or accept descriptions can be withdrawn without first demanding a named refusal, explanation or replacement. This applies beyond administrative records: a word does not become what it names, and no learned word—including “fact”, “agreement” and the words here—gets an exception. That observation does not by itself prove the proposal.

    In your example, could the existing agreement have been used without requiring that submission, or is there a further difficulty this misses?

    Kirill Shebetov, Beforeword

  7. Andrew Usher said,

    October 25, 2026 @ 12:38 pm

    That post, I think, exemplifies the kind of frustration such products cause – normal people simply don't have those presuppositions about how things should work.

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a Comment